Why Both Groups Received Cash in a Trial of Alcohol-Monitoring Incentives

Illustration of specimen tubes, evidence bags, and documentation on a laboratory bench

Written by

in

Barnett and colleagues randomly assigned 30 adults who reported heavy drinking to two payment arrangements. One group received escalating payments tied to days with neither reported nor detected drinking. The comparison group received payments on a schedule yoked to participants in the contingent group. Their payments did not depend on their own drinking.

What the comparison isolates

Both groups could receive money, so the trial tested the effect of linking the payment to the measured behavior. During the intervention, the adjusted proportion of days without sensor-detected drinking was 54.3% in the contingent group and 31.2% in the comparison group. The difference in weekly self-reported drink counts did not reach statistical significance.

Check whether the outcome survives follow-up

The follow-up lacked an objective measure of drinking. Its self-reported comparison of the longest streak without drinking was statistically inconclusive. The study offers a preliminary test of a reinforcement schedule while it operated. A later study could retain sensor measurement at follow-up and track whether the observed difference persisted after payments ended.

Source

Barnett et al., Addiction, 2017

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *